Ten different Pittsburgh Penguins players have scored four, or more, goals in a regular season game.
Pittsburgh Penguins with Four Goals in Same Game
| Date | Player | Team | Goalie / Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12/13/1980 | Paul Gardner | v. Philadelphia | Myre |
| 12/5/1984 | Mike Bullard | v. St. Louis | Liut |
| 12/31/1985 | Mario Lemieux | @ St. Louis | Wamsley |
| 12/31/1985 | Mario Lemieux | v. Toronto | Wregget (3) Bester |
| 3/3/1987 | Randy Cunneyworth | @ Quebec | Gosselin (3) Malarchuk |
| 4/2/1988 | Mario Lemieux | @ Washington | Malarchuk |
| 12/31/1988 | Mario Lemieux | v. New Jersey | Sauve (3) & Terrerri & ENG (five goals) |
| 3/30/1989 | Mario Lemieux | v. Hartford | Whitmore |
| 1/8/1990 | Mario Lemieux | @ NY Rangers | Froese (2) & Vanbiesbrouck (2) |
| 11/29/1991 | Kevin Stevens | @ Philadelphia | Roussel (2) & Wregget (2) |
| 12/23/1991 | Joe Mullen | @ NYIslanders | Healy |
| 12/26/1991 | Joe Mullen | v. Toronto | Fuhr (consecutive games) |
| 10/17/1992 | Kevin Stevens | @ Hartford | Burke (3) & Pietrangelo |
| 3/18/1993 | Mario Lemieux | v. Washington | Beaupre (3) & Hrivnak |
| 3/20/1993 | Mario Lemieux | v. Philadelphia | Soderstrom (3) & Roussel (consecutive games) |
| 4/9/1993 | Mario Lemieux | @ NY Rangers | Hirsch (3) & Richter (2) (five goals) |
| 2/6/1995 | Luc Robitaille | v. Hartford | Reese |
| 11/30/1995 | Mario Lemieux | @ Boston | Bailey (2) & Billington (2) |
| 3/5/1996 | Petr Nedved | v. Winnipeg | Khabibulin (2) & Roussel (2) |
| 1/26/1997 | Mario Lemieux | @ Montreal | Thibault |
| 10/14/2000 | Jaromir Jagr | v. NY Rangers | McLean |
| 2/3/2013 | Chris Kunitz | @ Washington | Holtby |